Featured

Cousin Conversation: AI and Photographs

Image: rawpixel.com

  

"I tweaked a photo of Stephen. What do you think?" 

Uh oh, was my honest knee-jerk reaction.  

The missive came from one of the Hub's distant cousins. I'll call him Cousin X. I'd corresponded with him in the past, and several years ago, he sent me a copy of the image I had seen on Find a Grave of Stephen Casey, the Hub's fourth great-grandfather. 

I'll admit, I don't use AI unless it's a tool built into a website I use, such as optical character recognition on Newspapers.com or FamilySearch's full-text search or transcription tools. Make my life easier? Cool. But I haven't gone any farther. Call me a Luddite, but it's just a line I haven't brought myself to cross yet, for all sorts of reasons. 

So, while my knee-jerk reaction would have been to dismiss out of hand Cousin X's effort to improve the image, I decided to slow down and be...curious. The resulting conversation was really fruitful, as it helped me understand what he did, how he did it, and how he thought about using AI for this purpose. 

And it got me thinking critically about photos/images in general, and how many different versions of a photo there might be floating around in our filing cabinets, digital files, websites, etc. Do we ever think about where they came from or why they may look the way they do? Do we know if they are original, derivative, or something in between? Does it matter? 

Cousin X told me that another cousin held the original photograph of Stephen. She handed out photocopies of the original photo at a family reunion years ago and Cousin X got one. He brought it home and scanned it. That's the image that he sent me and posted to Find a Grave. By the time the image got to me, it was already third generation. And when he used ChatGPT to see if he could sharpen and clean it up, the resulting image was the fourth generation.

Generation 1: Original photo

> Generation 2: Photocopy of original

>> Generation 3: Scan of photocopy

>>> Generation 4: AI enhancement of digital scan  

Or put another way, the image Cousin X sent me was the great-grandchild of the original photo!

How I would love to have all four generations of this image laid side-by-side on a table to compare them. 

There's no denying that the image that Cousin X sent me is beautiful. The lines are crisp and clear. There was more contrast to the image than the digitized one he had sent me years ago. But I have to ask, "How accurate is it?"

Cousin X used ChatGPT to enhance the image of Stephen Casey from a prior digital scan.1

 

I put the original scan Cousin X first sent me (version 1) and the AI-enhanced version (version 2)—next to each other to compare. And I could definitely see differences. Age spots on Stephen's hands that were visible on version 1 were gone in version 2. Clothing details that were not visible in version 1 were crystal clear in version 2. One example: only one vest button is visible in the image I have, yet there are three vest buttons on the AI-enhanced version. Similarly, it appears that Stephen's jacket might have cuffed sleeves in my version, yet the sleeves are smooth in the enhanced image. Stephen looks sort of worn out in my image, but hale and hearty in the other! 

This image of Stephen Casey is a digitized version of a photocopy of an original photograph.2

How accurate are those changes? Obviously, erasing things like age spots makes the AI version inaccurate. And improving the detail in the clothing begs the question, "How does ChatGPT know the details of the clothing he was wearing?" Perhaps it's making a best guess based on other similar photos in its knowledge base. Or maybe Stephen's vest was missing two buttons. A guess is just that. 

Cousin X asked for my opinion of the image. "While I think the tweaks look great, I think without having access to the original or the photocopy to compare, I know I would prefer the earliest iteration of the image that I have, as it would be the closest generation-wise to the actual photograph," I wrote. "It's then also closer to the image that resulted from the technology of the time it was taken, in spite of what we might consider modern-day imperfections."  

Cousin X was honest in his opinion of using this technology to make improvements to photographs. "I do have mixed opinions on AI. I do make a distinction between AI generated and AI tweaked. If you want to generate images for your own amusement...go for it. I don't think you should put those out as authentic. I don't have a problem with tweaking and cleaning up damaged or faded photos. I don't see that as being different from taking a damaged photo to a photo shop to get it 'restored.'" That's a good point. Compare it to "retouching" that erased acne and tamed flyaway hair on high school photos of bygone days.

I wondered if Cousin X would indicate in some way that this newest image was AI-enhanced if he widely shared it. "I'm on the fence about that," he responded. "If the AI changes the photo dramatically...I won't even share it. If it turns out great, I will certainly share, as I did the Stephen photo with you. And I did tell you it was tweaked. I won't lie about it...lol." I appreciate that. 

Why is all this important? 

Well, as we preserve our photographs by scanning them or we enhance a faded image by using AI, we need to be cognizant that we may introduce changes to that historical image. We're taking a step—sometimes many steps—away from the original, as is the case with Stephen's enhanced photo.

And, we have a responsibility to let others know that we've done. Otherwise, how will anyone in the future know what is an actual historical photograph vs. a digital scan of a photocopy vs. a completely AI-created image? The internet gives us plenty of ways to share images digitally, removing the opportunity to compare new versions to older ones for accuracy.

It's about critical thinking, too. I have used online tools to "fix" or "enhance" images myself, with barely any thought about what I was doing. Now I realize I need to be honest about what I've done, so that those looking at images on my blog or elsewhere in the future will not confuse what I've changed and posted with what the actual image may have looked like, for better or worse.

What do you think? How have you used technology to change or improve photographs? Do you disclose that you've done so? How much has AI changed an image you sought to improve? Do you see an issue with that? Let me know in the comments.

And my thanks to Cousin X for the conversation and permission to share it here. 

Until next time... 

 

NOTES 

1 Stephen Casey, unknown photographer, undated, image enhanced by ChatGPT from a digital scan of a photocopy of original photograph, by [privatized], 2026. Image sent to Nancy Gilbride Casey, 30 October 2026.

2 Stephen Casey, unknown photographer, undated, digital image scanned from a photocopy of an original photograph, by [privatized]. Image sent to Nancy Gilbride Casey about 2019. 

 


 

 

Comments