Skip to main content

Featured

"Applying Lessons Learned" When Researching Female Ancestors

Image by rawpixel.com   Women in our family trees frequently get short shrift, don't they? With maiden names often undiscovered, they sometime languish, faded and unknown, next to their better-documented husbands on our family trees. Records don't often exist for them, distant descendants might not know their names, or they died without progeny to remember and carry their names forward. What if there was a resource that could help you discover more about those silent women to bring them out of the shadows? Such a resources exists in Telling Her Story: A Guide to Writing About Women of the Past by Sharon DeBartolo Carmack (Salt Lake City: Scattered Leaves Press, 2024). I used what I learned from this book to craft a series of blog posts on my great-great-great grandmother Mary Jane Sheridan. And I wrote about that process in the article: "Applying Lessons Learned," for the September 2025 issue of  Stirpes , the Journal of the Texas State Genealogical Society. Read it...

Heirloom Investigation: Where Did This Cutlery Set Come From? Part 2



I'm on a quest to find out more about a cutlery set that was recently given to me. Last week, we looked at the objects themselves and described them. I shared that my father-in-law recalled his grandmother used the set in her home, and that it had been passed on from his grandmother to his mother, and then to him.

And I had some theories.

This week, I'm sharing what I've found out about the set by following the clues. I researched in newspapers, a Sears catalog, various historical websites, and more.

What did I find out? 

 

Wyoming Cutlery Co., Formerly Sanson Cutlery Co.

A newspaper notice announced the name change of the Sanson Cutlery Company of Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, to the Wyoming Cutlery Co., in December 1895. A brief history of the Sanson Cutlery Co. appearing in another newspaper in December 1894 noted that the company had started in June 1887 and was established on Horton Street in Wilkes-Barre.1

The Wyoming Cutlery Company began as Sanson Cutlery Company in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania.2

This detail of a Sanborn Fire Insurance Map shows the Wyoming Cutlery Co. in 1910.3


By 1894, the company employed 150 men and boys, who produced large quantities of cutlery in every style which was "put up in attractive boxes containing six knives and six forks." The company claimed that the sets were in demand, "...in every State and Territory."4 

By 1919, however, the board of Wyoming Cutlery Co. filed a petition to dissolve its charter and end its corporate existence. Their building had been idle since 1914 and in 1918 was bought by the Perma-Loc Co. A final accounting was held on 3 April 1925 to complete the dissolution process.5

Conclusions:

  • The Wyoming Cutlery Co. set I have must have been produced between late 1895 and 1914. The set is not Civil War-era vintage.
  • The box the cutlery set was in cannot be original, as it bears a postage label dated 1949. 
  • None of the women in the line of provenance lived in Pennsylvania or had connections to that state of which I am aware. There was no suggestion that either Sanson or Wyoming Cutlery Company sold their wares by mail order. This suggests that the set was purchased in one of the states that they lived in: Ohio, Kansas, or Oklahoma. 

 

What Was the Set Made Of?

I learned a lot about cutlery during this research!  

  • Historically, this type of set was known as "The Peoples Cutlery" and produced between 1866 and 1920. They were made of carbon steel with exotic wood handles such as cocobolo (often referred to as "coco"), ebony, or rosewood, with inlaid pewter designs. Cocobolo is a South American wood used extensively for cutlery handles historically.6
  • Prior to the Civil War, guilds in Sheffield, England, had a monopoly on producing and distributing table cutlery, but this came to an end as American manufacturing adopted mass production practices.7
  • The 1894 Sanson Cutlery Co. history noted that their sets were made "with iron, ebony, coco, or bone handles." Since the knives and forks have a wood handle, and based on the color and markings, it most likely is cocobolo.8 
  • The tines of the forks and blade of the knives are made of carbon steel; the utensils' magnetic property helped me identify the metal as steel.9

A magnet firmly stuck to the knife blade. This tells me it is made of carbon steel.

  • Similar cutlery sets were sold in the Sears Roebuck Catalog in 1897, but these were stamped with American Cutlery Company, not Wyoming Cutlery Company. The catalog descriptions helped confirm that these types of utensils were made from carbon steel and cocobolo wood handles. They were similarly "double bolstered" meaning they had an end cap on both the knife end nearest the blade and the handle end, just like mine. They also had inlaid pewter designs similar to mine and a single pin in the handle to secure the wood pieces to the metal "tang."10
 

The 1897 Sears catalog advertised steel and cocobolo knives with similar patterns to my set.

 
The utensils in my set are "double bolstered," having an end cap on both sides of the handle.

 
  • While I had a hard time finding advertising for either Sanson or Wyoming cutlery, I did find one for "Wilkes-Barre Cutlery from Sanson Cutlery Co." in an 1889 Boston Store advertisement in a Wilkes-Barre newspaper.11


Conclusions:

  • The metal used is carbon steel, not silver, though the inlaid portion of the handles is likely pewter. So I was half right!
  • The wood is cocobolo, a type I was unfamiliar with. It was commonly used for table cutlery sold throughout the U.S. Similar cutlery was sold in the Sears catalog under the American Cutlery Co. label.
  • The Boston Store newspaper ad tells me that this cutlery could have been sold in department or home goods stores.

 

Who Bought the Set and Where?

As it turns out, any one of the three women in my father-in-law's line could have bought the set, and/or passed it on through the family.

My first guess was that the set was originally bought by Clarissa Blackman Kelso, my father-in-law's great-grandmother. Clarissa lived between 1857-1951. Wyoming Cutlery produced their wares between 1895 and 1914. Clarissa lived in Logan County, Oklahoma, at the time Wyoming Cutlery was in business and would have been between 38-57 years old during that time.12 

Clarissa's mother, Elizabeth Butler Blackman (1834-1907), was also in the picture during this time. She outlived her husband Dewitt Blackman by a dozen years and received the patent on their homestead in Logan County, Oklahoma, in 1895. She would have been between 60-72 years old when Wyoming Cutlery was being produced.

And my father-in-law's grandmother, Edna Kelso Hall (1883-1975)—whom he remembers using the utensils—was between 12-31 years old when Wyoming Cutlery Co. was in business, and also lived in Logan County, Oklahoma.13

There might have been a greater chance of Clarissa or Elizabeth purchasing the set, as they were adults most of the time that Wyoming Cutlery Co. was in business. In her later years, Clarissa Kelso lived with her daughter Edna Hall. If Clarissa inherited or was given the cutlery by her mother, Elizabeth, she might have brought the set when she moved and it became part of the Hall household goods.

Recall that the Sanson Cutlery Company history stated their wares were "...in demand by the general trade in every State and Territory," and that the cutlery was sold at the Boston Store in Wilkes-Barre. 

Ironically, I found that there was also a Boston Store housed in the Foucart Building in Guthrie, Oklahoma—less than 15 miles away from Crescent, where Edna lived after she married. There was a location in Chandler, Oklahoma, as well—about 60 miles from Crescent. Though these stores were independent of the store selling Sanson Cutlery (later Wyoming Cutlery), in Wilkes-Barre, they also sold housewares, etc.14

Foucart Building in Guthrie, home of the Boston Store in the early 1900s. (Wikimedia Commons)

 

The Boston Store building in Chandler, Oklahoma. (Wikimedia Commons)

The existence of these Boston Stores during the time Elizabeth, Clarissa, and Edna lived in Logan County suggests that perhaps the Wyoming Cutlery Co. set was sold at one of them. Any of the three women could have had the opportunity to purchase a set at either store, which were within reasonable distance of their homes. 

Edna Hall and Clarissa Kelso lived in Crescent (blue), while Elizabeth Blackman lived in Rose Hill (pink). Boston Stores were located in both Guthrie and Chandler (green). (Wikimedia Commons)15


It's been fun to learn about this neat set of cutlery and how it might have come into our family. 

Have you looked into the history and context of a family heirloom? Let me know in the comments.

Until next time... 


NOTES 

1 "Cutlery Works' New Name," Wilkes-Barre Daily News-Dealer (Pennsylvania), 28 Dec. 1895, p. 3, col. 3; imaged, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/article/wilkes-barre-times-leader-the-evening-n/206213664/ : accessed 19 Sept. 2026). Also, "The Sanson Cutlery Co. Manufacturers of Table Cutlery, Horton Street," The Times Leader (Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania), 19 Dec. 1894, p. 21, cols. 5-6; imaged, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/article/wilkes-barre-times-sanson-cutlery-works/206215965/ : accessed 19 Sept. 2026). 

2 "The Sanson Cutlery Co. Manufacturers of Table Cutlery, Horton Street," The Times Leader (Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania), 19 Dec. 1894. 

3 Sanborn Map Company, Insurance maps of Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, Vol. 2, 1910 (New York: Sanborn Map Company, 1910), p. 51, Wyoming Cutlery Co.; imaged, Penn State University Libraries Digital Collections (https://digital.libraries.psu.edu/digital/collection/maps1/id/23257 : accessed 22 Sept. 2026); citing Penn State University Libraries, State College.  

4 "The Sanson Cutlery Co. Manufacturers of Table Cutlery, Horton Street," The Times Leader (Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania), 19 Dec. 1894.  

5 "To Dissolve Its Charter," The Times Leader (Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania), 14 Aug. 1919, p. 12, cols. 6-7; imaged, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-times-leader-wyoming-cutlery-dissolv/206216022/ : accessed 19 Sept. 2026). Also, "Buys Perma-Loc Plant: Wyoming Tire & Rubber Company Takes Over South Wilkes-Barre Industry," The Wilkes Barre Record (Penns.), 20 October 1920, p. 16, cols. 1-2; imaged, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/image/392200755/ : accessed 20 Sept. 2026). Also, "In the Court of Common Pleas...," Times-Leader (Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania), 20 March 1925, p. 37, col. 1, Sixth and Final Accounting; imaged, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/image/137989795/ : accessed 21 Sept. 2026).

6 Museum of Our Industrial Heritage, New and Temporary Displays, "Inlaid Cutlery Pattern Display: Cutlery in the Valley" (https://industrialhistory.org/k/2039/Inlaid-Cutlery-Pattern-Display : accessed 22 Sept. 2026). 

7 Ibid. 

8 "The Sanson Cutlery Co. Manufacturers of Table Cutlery, Horton Street," The Times Leader (Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania), 19 Dec. 1894. 

9 PrimeWeld Blog (https://primeweld.com/blogs/news/how-to-identify-metals : accessed 19 Sept. 2026), "How To Identify Metals." 

10 1897 Sears, Roebuck and Co., Consumers Guide, Catalogue No 104, p. 107, Table Cutlery; imaged, HathiTrust (https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=ufl.31262033795401&seq=149&q1=cutlery : accessed 21 Sept. 2026); citing State University System of Florida. 

11 "Wilkes-Barre Cutlery," Boston Store advertisement, Wilkes-Barre Sunday Morning Leader, 8 December 1889, p. 5, col. 5; imaged, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/image/166903702/ : accessed 22 Sept. 2026). 

12 Gilbride/Casey Family Tree, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/family-tree/person/tree/34074975/person/150089040404/facts : accessed 3 October 2026), profile for Clarissa Blackman. 

13 Gilbride/Casey Family Tree, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/family-tree/person/tree/34074975/person/150089025624/facts : accessed 3 Oct. 2026), profile for Edna Abigal Kelso.

14 The Active Historian (https://theactivehistorian.com/2024/04/01/historic-markers-in-guthrie-ok/ : posted 1 April 2024), "Historic Markers in Guthrie, OK," Foucart Building. Also, Olivia DiMauro, "9 Old-Timey General Stores in Oklahoma," WorldAtlas (https://www.worldatlas.com/places/9-old-timey-general-stores-in-oklahoma-2026.html : posted 3 June 2026), Boston Store.

15 Oklahoma Department of Highways,+ Map of Oklahoma's state highway system, published by Oklahoma Department of Highways 50 miles (=Om. 083 ; 1 - 972 500 environ) - btv1b531927425 (Chicago, Illin.: Gorand Publishing, 1948); imaged, Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_Oklahoma%27s_state_highway_system,_published_by_Oklahoma_Department_of_Highways_50_miles_(%3DOm._083_;_1_-_972_500_environ)_-_btv1b531927425_(1_of_2).jpg : accessed 22 Oct. 2026).



Comments

  1. Did not know about the history of this type of cutlery, so I appreciated your deep dive into its origin. Plus it's magnetic! I do know that many areas had so-called Boston Stores, far far from Massachusetts.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Marian. I read that too, that the Boston Store was common name for household goods stores. Glad that you found the info useful. I sure didn't know anything about this type of cutlery, so it was fun.

      Delete
  2. Sandra Robertson-your use of maps and pictures of the buildings that had been stores are helpful elements in the history of where the set could have been purchased.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Fascinating story about the cutlery. You really delved deeply into the history.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm glad there was so much to dig into! Thanks for reading.

      Delete
  4. Very interesting details that you've uncovered. You found so much about the company and where stores sold the product. Too bad you couldn't definitely say who bought the cutlery and where. If only there was just one store where they lived . . . . Some mysteries can't be solved but you did a great job sleuthing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Linda. I would lay odds that the set was purchased in Guthrie, since it was so close. Chandler would have been a bit of a hike. Thank you for reading and commenting!

      Delete
  5. What a fun investigation, Nancy! It's amazing how much history you uncovered from one cutlery set! I especially loved how you used newspapers, catalogs, and maps to piece together its possible origins. 😊

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad you enjoyed it Diane! It was fun to research! Thanks for reading and commenting.

      Delete

Post a Comment